1896 – Miss Sarah J. Veeder
1897 – Miss Flora E. Williams
1898 – Lucy Catherine Chapin
1899 – Charles Bertram Walker
1901 – Grace M. Church
1903 – Associate Professor C.T. Hawley
1904 – Hildegard Mary Edwards
1908 – Josephine Holden Best
1909 – William Mathews Hekking
1910 – Eli Delbert Maybee
1911 – Charles Earl Bradley
1912 – Hilda Grossman
1913 – Margaret Chaplin
1914 – Joseph Edwin Burgess
1915 – William Clifford Hopple
1916 – Joseph Davis
1918 – Ethel Fay Hoffman
1919 – Lavinia Mary Wands
1920 – Charles Eugene Bracker
1921 – Bradley Walder Tomlin
1922 – Emma Marion Peters
1923 – Tressa Emerson
1924 – Virginia Phillips
1925 – Marian Bruce
1926 – Helen Porchet
1927 – Anne Paula Hueber
1928 – Marcia E. North
1929 – Mary Stowell
1930 – Beatrice Wose
1931 – Beatrice Donovan
1932 – Alan Flavelle
1933 – Mildred Damon
1934 – Anthony Tony
1935 – Audrey Mae Skaling
1936 – Elenore Stuart Bulmer
1937 – Elizabeth Ellis
1938 – Jack Weinstein
1939 – Jeanne Louise Stauffer
1940 – Robert A. Goodnough
1941 – Margaret Emerson
1942 – Richard Clayton Jeffery
1943 – Anna Ashton Shillinger
1944 – Roberta Adelene Jacoby
1945 – James H. Kleege
1946 – Allen Joseph Wolf
1947 – Robert S. Fuller
1950 – ALbert W. Gallagher
1952 – Leonard J. Slatkes
1956 – Darrell Sweet
1957 – Carolyn Strickler
1958 – Lois Pierson
1959 – Barbara Weiner
1960 – Gracia L. Melanson
1961 – Reed Alan Thomason
1962 – Richard Rappaport (Honorable Mention: Glenn Miller)
1963 – Carol Ann Levy
1964 – Sharon P. Yates
1965 – Thomas E. Black
1966 – Juris K. Ubans
1967 – Nancy Shaffer
1968 – Laura M. Tice
1969 – Nelson W. Hegeman

Note: No names were found for missing years, and no reasons were given for why they were missing.